Skip to main content
Claudia Kruschel
    Download (.pdf)
    Download (.pdf)
    We derive statistical properties of standard methods for monitoring of habitat cover worldwide, and criticize them in the context of mandated seagrass monitoring programs, as exemplified by Posidonia oceanica in the Mediterranean Sea. We... more
    We derive statistical properties of standard methods for monitoring of habitat cover worldwide, and criticize them in the context of mandated seagrass monitoring programs, as exemplified by Posidonia oceanica in the Mediterranean Sea. We report the novel result that cartographic methods with non-trivial classification errors are generally incapable of reliably detecting habitat cover losses less than about 30 to 50%, and the field labor required to increase their precision can be orders of magnitude higher than that required to estimate habitat loss directly in a field campaign. We derive a universal utility threshold of classification error in habitat maps that represents the minimum habitat map accuracy above which direct methods are superior. Widespread government reliance on blind-sentinel methods for monitoring seafloor can obscure the gradual and currently ongoing losses of benthic resources until the time has long passed for meaningful management intervention. We find two classes of methods with very high statistical power for detecting small habitat cover losses: 1) fixed-plot direct methods, which are over 100 times as efficient as direct random-plot methods in a variable habitat mosaic; and 2) remote methods with very low classification error such as geospatial underwater videography, which is an emerging, low-cost, non-destructive method for documenting small changes at millimeter visual resolution. General adoption of these methods and their further development will require a fundamental cultural change in conservation and management bodies towards the recognition and promotion of requirements of minimal statistical power and precision in the development of international goals for monitoring these valuable resources and the ecological services they provide.
    Sediment movement is a major force in the evolutionary ecology of seagrasses. Sediment movement can cause retreat or expansion of the seagrass bed, and sorting of species according to their tolerances of erosion or deposition. The... more
    Sediment movement is a major force in the evolutionary ecology of seagrasses. Sediment movement can cause retreat or expansion of the seagrass bed, and sorting of species according to their tolerances of erosion or deposition. The objectives of this study were 1) to assess the effectiveness of DGPS/videography in demonstrating sediment movement and seagrass bed expansion, 2) to quantify changes in species composition or bed expanse/retreat in response to sediment movement using this method. During 2007, 2008 and 2009, 23 transects in the Novigrad Sea were monitored using a boat-based DGPS videography. Three seagrass species occur in this area: Zostera noltii, Zostera marina and Cymodocea nodosa. They form a continuous mixed meadow from the surface to a depth of 6,6 m on sandy or muddy substrate. Video analysis with sonography gave us information on ground type, ground cover, seagrass density, and depth. Seagrass gain occurred in 2007/2008, the year of net sediment accumulation, whil...
    Download (.doc)
    Evidence for competition between two co-occurring seagrass species, Zostera is given.
    Download (.pdf)
    The importance of seagrass meadows as a habitat for fish assemblages has been documented in numerous studies worldwide. P. oceanica meadows in the Mediterranean provide valuable habitat for fish species, including food sources and refuge... more
    The importance of seagrass meadows as a habitat for fish assemblages has been documented in numerous studies worldwide. P. oceanica meadows in the Mediterranean provide valuable habitat for fish species, including food sources and refuge from predators for juveniles and adults. We assembled all published research on fish assemblages associated with P. oceanica meadows, and performed a meta-analysis that tests hypotheses regarding the drivers of community structure across all of these studies. We found a total of 14 published research articles containing fish species abundance data at P. oceanica meadows between 1982 and 2010, with an average of just under two sampled fish communities per study. The results show the presence of 112 taxa (fish richness ranging from 27 to 53 per paper, 41 on average), in P.oceanica meadows within a depth range from 1.0 to 40.0 meters. Studies varied in sampling method (skid trawl, visual census, beam trawl), time of day (day/night), and protection leve...
    Ecological differences along the Adriatic Sea (climatic differences along the NW-SE axis, higher eutrophication in the North Adriatic, and higher natural eutrophication in the area between the islands or inside deep indented bays)... more
    Ecological differences along the Adriatic Sea (climatic differences along the NW-SE axis, higher eutrophication in the North Adriatic, and higher natural eutrophication in the area between the islands or inside deep indented bays) influence Posidonia oceanica distribution and the appearance of its meadows. As the baselines of descriptors for Posidonia meadows for a particular area in the Croatian Adriatic have not yet been established we argue that non-critical and untested use of baselines of descriptors and classification methods that exist for Posidonia meadows in the NW Mediterranean could lead to erroneous conclusions and an incorrect assessment of meadow conservation status. Introduction The Adriatic Sea is the northernmost part of the Mediterranean. There are notable ecological differences along the Adriatic such as climatic differences along the NW-SE axis, as well as higher eutrophication in the North Adriatic, and higher natural and human impacted eutrophication in the are...
    Download (.pdf)
    Regular monitoring of Posidonia oceanica (L.) (Posidoniaceae) is required under EC directives, and its purpose is to inform management agencies when and where actions are necessary to protect and restore ecological health and water... more
    Regular monitoring of Posidonia oceanica (L.) (Posidoniaceae) is required under EC directives, and its purpose is to inform management agencies when and where actions are necessary to protect and restore ecological health and water quality. The Habitats Directive requires each EU member nation to report specifically on temporal trend in areal extent of Posidonia habitat. The success of the HD hinges on the power of the monitoring protocol to reveal a significant negative trend, wherever that trend occurs in nature. Statistical power is determined by the size of the sampling error of the protocol, which includes measurement uncertainty and natural spatial variation in the descriptor. We review several descriptors of Posidonia status, and consider published estimates of their typical sampling errors, to compare their ability to demonstrate a 10% temporal trend. We find that the protocols with potentially high statistical power are fixed-plot methods such as SeagrassNet and balisage, h...
    Download (.pdf)
    Sažetak: In the Mediterranean, the seagrass Posidonia oceanica (L.) Delile is considered highly threatened and therefore holds habitat priority status under Natura 2000. Because the extent and health of Posidonia in the Croatian Adriatic... more
    Sažetak: In the Mediterranean, the seagrass Posidonia oceanica (L.) Delile is considered highly threatened and therefore holds habitat priority status under Natura 2000. Because the extent and health of Posidonia in the Croatian Adriatic is currently unknown, we ...
    Download (.pdf)
    Download (.pdf)
    Download (.pdf)
    Download (.pdf)
    Predation of fish assemblages in seagrass meadows was examined in the field and in tank experiments. Lure trolling indicated that (1) total abundance of fish was higher on bare sediment where small fish (<5 cm), including juveniles,... more
    Predation of fish assemblages in seagrass meadows was examined in the field and in tank experiments. Lure trolling indicated that (1) total abundance of fish was higher on bare sediment where small fish (<5 cm), including juveniles, predominated; (2) abundance was lowest in seagrass where large fish (>15 cm) predominated; (3) large ambush predators, primarily the grass goby and European eel, were almost completely restricted to seagrass; (4) the predation mode in seagrass was almost entirely ambushing or stalk-attacking, while the predation mode on bare sediment was almost entirely chase-attacking; (5) ambush predation was far more successful than chase-attack predation; and (6) overall predation risk was approximately three times higher in seagrass. Tank experiments showed that piscivory success of the grass goby was higher than that of the most common chase-attacker, the black goby, and the presence or absence of artificial seagrass, regardless of density, had no significant effect on predation success of either species. Guts of the grass goby contained food items of a wider size range that averaged twice the size of those of the black goby. Our results confirm our prediction that the risk of predation, especially of small/juvenile fish, is higher in seagrass meadows than at adjacent bare substrate, and this risk differential is explained by the presence of larger, more efficient ambush predators restricted to seagrass, and the scarcity of large chase-attack predators in the Novigrad Sea.
    Download (.pdf)
    Within the scope of a seagrass monitoring program in the Novigrad Sea, Central Croatian Adriatic, we predicted that the annual variability in coverage of seagrasses (Zostera marina, Zostera noltii, and Cymodocea nodosa) can be partially... more
    Within the scope of a seagrass monitoring program in the Novigrad Sea, Central Croatian Adriatic, we predicted that the annual variability in coverage of seagrasses (Zostera marina, Zostera noltii, and Cymodocea nodosa) can be partially explained by the annual variability in sediment translocation. From 23 fixed DGPS-referenced monitoring video transects followed over three years (June 2007–2009), we calculated annual (i) changes in interior bed seagrass coverage, (ii) gain in seagrass at the lower edge of the bed and seagrass bed expansion, and (iii) accumulation of sediment, its depth dependence, and the associated changes in transect slope. We found that in 2007 to 2008, the year with net sediment accumulation, seagrass coverage increased and the bed expanded. In both years seagrass cover within the seagrass bed increased with increasing sediment accumulation, while seagrass bed expansion was highest under intermediate sedimentation rates. Boat-based videographic monitoring can document both natural sediment movement along the depth gradient, and species-specific responses necessary for informed management of submerged aquatic vegetation in the Adriatic Sea.► Boat-based underwater videography is a rapid and inexpensive method of monitoring small changes in seagrass cover. ► This method was applied to a mixed-species sward of seagrasses in a Croatian Adriatic lagoon. ► Seagrass cover increased over a two year period coincident with a net sediment influx. ► Sediments can increase seagrass habitat by filling in areas too deep for sufficient light penetration. ► Sediment movement may also eliminate species relatively intolerant of burial (such as Zostera marina or Zostera noltii) and favor those more tolerant (such as Cymodocea nodosa).
    Download (.pdf)
    Schultz.Boat-based..._prihvacen_u_Aquatic_botany.pdf
    Kruschel2009.seagrasscompetition.NovigradskoMore.pdf
    The vertical gliding motility patterns of Oscillatoria cf. laetevirens and Spirulina cf. subsalsa from hypersaline ponds near Guerrero Negro, Mexico, were monitored under natural solar irradiance. Each of these two filamentous... more
    The vertical gliding motility patterns of Oscillatoria cf. laetevirens and Spirulina cf. subsalsa from hypersaline ponds near Guerrero Negro, Mexico, were monitored under natural solar irradiance. Each of these two filamentous cyanobacteria (and together) forms a distinct band within soft microbial mats. Upward and downward migration in excised mats was measured in response to different intensities of the full solar spectrum and of selected wavelengths, using various filters and screens. Positions of the cyanobacteria were quantified at the beginning and end of the treatments, using microscopic examination of minicores. In addition, photosynthetic rates of these cyanobacteria, using freshly collected cell material, were measured by 14C incorporation under different intensities and spectral regions of solar irradiance. Upward migration to or near the surface by either Spirulina or Oscillatoria occurred under low visible light (20–90 W m−2), green light (∼250 W m−2), red light (∼470 W m−2) and in complete darkness. It was prevented by intensities of UV-A above ∼1.5 W m−2 and by broad visible light above ∼100 W m−2. Incident UV-B intensities as low as 0.1 W m−2 may also have slowed movement upward. Downward migration of Spirulina cf. subsalsa was promoted by high UV or visible radiation. With a larger data set for Oscillatoria cf. laetivirens, it was apparent that downward migration occurred in response to visible light over ∼400 W m−2 and to relatively high levels of UV-A alone (>∼10 W m−2). If forced experimentally to remain on the surface during periods of high solar irradiance, both cyanobacterial species suffered photo and UV inhibition of photosynthesis, with UV-B and UV-A being particularly effective. Attenuation measurements within the mat showed that UV-A and UV-B wavelengths can penetrate deeply enough into mats to potentially act as positioning cues for these motile cyanobacteria, and as a consequence allow them to take refuge from higher intensities of damaging radiation.
    Download (.pdf)
    Research Interests:
    Download (.pdf)